Is Maxwell the worst FA acquisition in franchise history?

[headknocker]

Factor in the crazy money they threw at him and I can't think of a bigger bust than this jagoff. He's soft as hell and can't tackle or cover worth a damn.

What's not to like?

[TRENT]

can't really say yes

because this is the worst coached defense ever in Philadelphia,,and we had the Taco defense! so I would say jury is out until Davis is gone,,but it seems Jenkins has regressed the whole Defense looks turrible!

Between Him and Murray,,we have 2 to pick from

[Eagle In Ohio]

That "tackle" by Jenkins early in the game yesterday

because this is the worst coached defense ever in Philadelphia,,and we had the Taco defense! so I would say jury is out until Davis is gone,,but it seems Jenkins has regressed the whole Defense looks turrible!

Between Him and Murray,,we have 2 to pick from

Says it all. WTF was that ??? almost makes me ashamed to say that he's a former Buckeye.

[McNabbTime05]

I still think Nnamdi was worse

[IronEagle]

Honestly, I think the defense was playing ok, maybe even good until the Tampa game. Not sure how they fell off the cliff.

Losing Hicks hurt a lot but that explains nothing about this collapse.

Drafting Smith and Rowe have hurt as much as anything. I felt a little bad for Rowe yesterday... I think he's playing out of position.

[TRENT]

Yes! there U go...

I still think Nnamdi was worse

so far he's the worst DB we ever signed...Maxwell has a chance to catch him,,they both seem like Pussies

[The Ref]

Bbambi was much worse.

[Brandonn]

Murray is actually worse.

[headknocker]

All valid points (hard to argue) but something about Maxwell just rubs me the wrong way as he comes across as not really giving a shit. He drives me crazy with his lack of coverage skills but his lame-ass attempts at tackling send me over the edge. He always goes high which is something they teach you in the pee-wee leagues NOT to do. It's all about effort and wanting to be good but I just don't see any of it in him.

[ArkansasEagle]

His strip move

At the end of every "tackle" is the worst ever

[Eagle In Ohio]

Hell yes

At the end of every "tackle" is the worst ever

I hate that shit. the fucking guy is down already, they're not going to give you a fumble if you do happen to strip it.

[McCarthy12]

I think so too

[FuriousXGeorge]

Murray is actually worse.

This. Maxwell is not worth his contract, but he is a serviceable NFL starer. Murray right now should not even be on the field.

The Murray signing is also worse because it was necessitated by a dumbass trade of a better player that could have stayed here for the same price.

We had running back solved for years and made a hole there for no reason. CB was a position that had legitimate holes to begin with because we were coming off two cheap stopgap free agents that didn't work out.

[Ground_Meat]

I still think Nnamdi was worse

This. I'll give Roach-Murray #2.

[ishimonster]

Honestly, I think the defense was playing ok, maybe even good until the Tampa game. Not sure how they fell off the cliff.

Losing Hicks hurt a lot but that explains nothing about this collapse.

Drafting Smith and Rowe have hurt as much as anything. I felt a little bad for Rowe yesterday... I think he's playing out of position.

Rookie CB who hasn't started a game, didn't come into the game as a starter, 1-on-1 with no help against Calvin fucking Johnson. Unbelievable.