McNabb Or Wentz

[Joker]

McNabb won playoff games as well as puking. If TO and him could have gotten along, they would have won at least two superbowls. Wentz hasn't proven that he can win in big games. The 2004 team was the better team and its sad it didn't last

[Loki]

Mark Howe

[Maniac]

Wentz pouty baby act has done wonders for McNabb's reputation.

[broadstreetparade]

Carson Wentz would have been the Eagles best QB ever had he not torn his ACL againt LA. I am certain of it.

[EagleFanInMD]

One more tidbit


PASS yds-
McNabb- 32,873
Wentz-16,811

Passer Rtg
Mcnabb-82
Wentz-89-
Longest Rushing yd
Mcnabb 54
Wentz- 50

WORST 3 memories
McNabb
Throw- up
TO Drama
Tie/OT rule
Wentz
Tears ACL - but we won the superbowl
Paid to Much
Concusion

PLAYOFFS
aDVANTAGE mCNABB

[3rd & Inches]

Sex Panther > Big Dick Nick > Wild Boar Hunter > Dog Killer > Jeff “no days off” Garcia > Pig Stabber

*reid area to present

[Greenstealth]

mcnabb

[HEREisAKERS]

I still take Wentz because he actually seemed disappointed when he played like shit

[art vandelay]

McNabb and it's not even a question.

Times have changed since McNabb was QB but I'm astounded by the amount of rope Wentz got from this fan base compared to McNabb.

[BigSlizz]

McNabb. Every time.

[udontknowme]

Mcnabb by miles. The very best of Wentz might top 5...maybe...but 5 was very good for a very long time, and he won a lot of playoff games.

[IronEagle]

McNabb because he won a number of playoff games for the Eagles

[broadstreetparade]

Mcnabb because 5 will always love you and Wentz is a sandy vag.

[EagleFanInMD]

Now both are gone. Pick one you liked more. Of course wentz was shorter time. But if you had to pick.