Mega experts Mel Kiper and Todd McShay's

[JB]

latest mocks have us picking Geno Smith and Star Loteulei. Hope McShay is right

[Agent 10]

If Jordan is available it's gotta be him. They are desperate for a game changer on D. I rarely watch ESPN but did anyone see that sports science on Jordan. From the athletic standpoint he grades out close to D Ware. Obviously it's not on the field but can you really let that freak athletic ability pass you by.

[JB]

That's who I'd like to see as well...

Oregon connection...blah blah. We'll have to see what that means for Graham and the new free agents. Just pick best player available and go from there filling holes of which there are many on this squad.

[J Con]

but is he a football player? Not a whole lot of production given his physical tools as far as getting to the qb

[Agent 10]

JPP played like 7 games in college. Chris Gocong broke the NCAA record for sacks in a season. You never know.

[Loki]

Will Chip put his locker in a different place than it was

in college? He might to that to force him out of a comfort zone.

[J Con]

"you never know" is a game best played in later rounds not with the #4 overall pick

[Agent 10]

Couldn't agree more but can you tell me a sure fire non bust?? I can't tell you that so why not take a chance on an athlete. I really think ( I'm no expert by any means) that Joeckel is the only "safe" pick in the entire draft. The reason why I brought up JPP was because he was drafted on potential. Jordan up until his Junior year was a TE.

[RSE]

Mel was on NFL32 and explained his reasoning as follows:

1. He had Geno Smith going in the 20's at the beginning of the year, and he still thinks that Smith is at best a draft pick in the 20's.

2. However, many mock drafts lately have Geno Smith going high, in the top ten.

3. Based on all these mock drafts, Mel thinks he must be missing something, and decided to move him up into the top ten.

4. Mel then had to look for a slot for Smith, and he decided that the Eagles made the most sense.

THAT'S how an expert does it.

[Irish George]

thank God

latest mocks have us picking Geno Smith and Star Loteulei. Hope McShay is right

Kiper is never right.

[IronEagle]

Mel was on NFL32 and explained his reasoning as follows:

1. He had Geno Smith going in the 20's at the beginning of the year, and he still thinks that Smith is at best a draft pick in the 20's.

2. However, many mock drafts lately have Geno Smith going high, in the top ten.

3. Based on all these mock drafts, Mel thinks he must be missing something, and decided to move him up into the top ten.

4. Mel then had to look for a slot for Smith, and he decided that the Eagles made the most sense.

THAT'S how an expert does it.

Expert analysis!

Kudos to Kiper for giving us lay people insight into how an expert performs their analysis.