Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

My two cents on Vick

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • My two cents on Vick

    Vick’s the starter, and it was a no brainer for Chip if he is to maintain any credibility at all. He said the starter would emerge in the preseason, and Vick clearly has.

    Whether you like it or not, Vick is still a legend in the minds of some young players. I think that is unfortunate, but it is what it is. It may be a cultural thing, a generational thing, a gangsta thing, or whatever, but it is true. I believe that’s true for DJax and to a lesser extent for Shady. How could this coaching staff possibly have sold Foles over Vick to them? Certainly not based on their preseason performance.

    With that said, my first problem with Vick is that he is not self-motivated. He plays well with a chip (no pun intended) on his shoulder or when he’s got something to prove. He does not play well when he feels comfortable. The great quarterbacks compete with themselves to be the best they can be—not because they aspire to beat out the Nick Foles or Kevin Kolbs of the world. Chip’s quarterback competition may have brought out the best in Vick, but now let’s see if he can maintain that performance.

    My second problem with Vick is that he is not the most cerebral student of the game I’ve ever seen. Alright, he’s fucking stupid. But Vick will perform better in Chip’s offense because it doesn’t take an Einstein to run it. Vick clearly was way over his head in the FF’s offense. You could see him thinking, and thinking poorly. His confusion was readily apparent. In Chip’s offense, Vick will have less to think about. He will have one or two decisions to make in each play, not twenty. He will rely more on instinct than intellect.

    If he stays healthy, he really could thrive in this offense.

  • #2
    It will come down to his reads

    He's got enough talent and speed to make this offense click. Like you said, there are no 4-5 progression reads in Chip's offense. Chip went 13-1 in 2010 and 2012 with redshirt sophomore who played a quarter as a true freshman, and a redshirt freshman last year. Vick should be respected in the huddle, so that's not an issue. It all comes down to whether he can make the right reads, both pre snap and post snap.

    The biggest advantage to moving as fast as Chip likes to is you can pretty well predict what the defense will be on the play and the next play if you're not substituting. They can't sub and they can't really even change up the coverages much. It should all make things easier on Vick. One of the first things I heard about Kelly from the NFL front office types that made him such a hot commodity, was that he was able to score a lot of points without having a great QB. Darron Thomas and Jeremiah Spicoli are not even NFL QB's, and Mariota was a Freshman. If you buy that Chip can score points without an elite QB, then he should be able to score points with Vick.
    Last edited by eagleduck; 08-20-2013, 02:45 PM.

    Comment

    Working...
    X