The fate of Vick

[iowaigglefan]

Except Westbrook carried McNabb.

Exactly !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !

[slag]

Ridiculous statement.

[slag]

Oh, ok ... the defense was playing offense?

[slag]

Exactly wrong.

Unless you're a stone dope, you know Westbrook was not more important than McNabb to that offense.

Not even close.

[Greenstealth]

The success of backups (detmer, feeley, garcia) would suggest otherwise.

[slag]

Yeah right.

Their limited mediocre play proves it.

[slag]

PS - Whether you like it or not, Donovan McNabb is going to get serious consideration for the Hall of Fame.

Look at his numbers.

Then make more ridiculous statements about how Detmer and Feeley are proof of anything.

And Jeff Garcia was a legit NFL starter and a star in his own right, with 3 Pro Bowl appearances.

[SCREAMIN EAGLE]

PS - Whether you like it or not, Donovan McNabb is going to get serious consideration for the Hall of Fame.

Look at his numbers.

Then make more ridiculous statements about how Detmer and Feeley are proof of anything.

And Jeff Garcia was a legit NFL starter and a star in his own right, with 3 Pro Bowl appearances.

No he won't.

[slag]

Yes he will.

[AthensEagle]

The success of Detmer and Feeley? Huh? Must have been some quick success, I don't recall it.

[SCREAMIN EAGLE]

Yes he will.

Maybe a little considersation. For about 5 minutes and then the committee will move on afer thinking about it.

[TRENT]

No, not as important,,but look to the Carolina Game

and you will have your answer,,,Westy kept AR honest; enough to protect Nabby by calling some runs and screens,,,It was common Knowledge that No one on that Team scared the Panther besides westy and when he was out for that NFCCC we lost....I'm a big Donny blower,,always have been; but this is football,,,the Ultimate team sport,,,U win as a team and lose as a team..

The defense needs the Offense to possess the ball and give them rest,,,the defense needs to make plays and keep it close,,,special teams just needs to Not,,shit the bed.

[slag]

Do tell ... a running game is important?

Thanks.

I suppose you also think Terrell Davis was more important than Elway ... and Smith was more important than Aikman?

[SCREAMIN EAGLE]

Do tell ... a running game is important?

Thanks.

I suppose you also think Terrell Davis was more important than Elway ... and Smith was more important than Aikman?

Elway (Top 5 QB by the way) would not have 2 Super Bowl rings without Terrell Davis.

[slag]

Right