Roob Frank rates all Eagles 1st round draft picks since NFL-AFL merger

[IronEagle]

That's since 1970. Some memorable busts in here.

http://www.csnphilly.com/football-ph...rger-1st-round

Second and third rounds here. The busts and overall values of the picks here don't sting the nostrils quite as much, IMO.

http://www.csnphilly.com/football-ph...rger-2nd-round

http://www.csnphilly.com/football-ph...er-duce-staley

[Drama Queen]

The high level of second and third round busts are horrendous.

Ben Smith played like Dawkins in his first 2 years, IMO. That is such a what-if story for me. Without the knee injury, its possible that he would have played with Dawkins. Thought Sismore would be a little higher.

[Joegrane]

[QUOTE=IronEagle;1808351]That's since 1970. Some memorable busts in here.

http://www.csnphilly.com/football-ph...rger-1st-round


Strange that he did not find a way to include the great Reggie White, 1st round pick in the supplemental draft during the USFL days.

[Ellsworth]

That first round list would be hilarious except for the fact we are all still waiting for our first super bowl win.

Great organizations don't whiff on 75% of their first round picks. The fact maclin and Simon are top 7 says it all. Good players, sure. But ranked that high as all time first rounders pretty much says it all.

[Two Gap Penetrator]

Twitter has ruined some of these writers for me

I used to follow Ruben and he was tweeting absolutely bullsh*t every 2 seconds. The thing that made me stop following him was he was coming back from some game or something and he stopped at a gas station that offered dry cleaning and he tweeted about that. Les Bowen too. Tweets CONSTANTLY. Hey Les: If I'm following you on Twitter, there's a REASON for that. It's not so that I could read your EVERY THOUGHT!