Donovan Mcnabb in hindsight

[slag]

Such venom

Five will always love you

[RSE]

Even with the offensive talent he had to play with he really could have won and perhaps should have won four NFC championship games.

[TerpEagle]

How many key playoff games did McNabb lose?

He was a good player for the Eagles but I don't think he deserves a retired number.

As I said before, i don't think I'd buy him a dinner. Well, maybe under the right circumstances.

Fewer than Brian Dawkins.

EDIT TO ADD:

And TO.

[Drama Queen]

That’s right and you people damn well know it!

[Big Little]

Don’t forget about James Trash

The talent around Wentz and what McNabb had to work with are not comparable.

Just happy to see Howie getting it right - Fly 🦅’s Fly!!

[Drama Queen]

Don’t mention Brian Dawkins and McNabb in a comparison. And you damn well know not to...

[DEERSPINE GUY]

Even with the offensive talent he had to play with he really could have won and perhaps should have won four NFC championship games.

NOT WITH FF CALLING THE SHOTS.

[91EaglesD]

He wins multiple Super Bowls if they got him Alshon Jeffrey's equivalent his second year and you damn well know it.

And someone better than Correll fucking Buckhalter at RB.

He was fucking Michael Jordan early on.

So now we are retiring numbers based on hypotheticals? I prefer guys that show up when it matters like Mr. Foles

[slag]

Yes, that's true, and he's dislikable for his DUI's and Me Too issues and his mom whining etc.

But the fact remains that we're all forgetting that he was really fucking good, particularly early, and the season they got there he had Owens.

And I'm totally convinced if he had an Owens earlier, this thread doesn't happen.

[TerpEagle]

Don’t mention Brian Dawkins and McNabb in a comparison. And you damn well know not to...

They shared a lot of chokes together.

[slag]

Nice trolling ... I'm having some light sport here.

[Drama Queen]

McNabb’s first 5 years, I’ll give you that. McNabb and Reid laid a foundation throughout the organization. They brought stability.

I do not like McNabb like I once did.

[slag]

That's actually the point ... I bet half the people pissing on him now have his jersey in their closet.

[91EaglesD]

It’s one thing to own it and another to retire it

[Drama Queen]

Get the fuck out of here. No seriously. Time out. In the corner!