Lets continue the debate. McNabb was a great QB for the Eagles

[Big Little]

Agreed neither one of them are and if one gets in the other should as mentioned in this article.

https://247sports.com/nfl/philadelphia-eagles/Article/Comparing-resumes-of-Tony-Romo-and-Donovan-McNabb-52144783/

[BirdBrawn]

Close but no cigar

Hall of Fame is 1A
McNabb is 1B. Very good, but not elite.

Matthew Stafford is a 1B. So is Matt Ryan. Guys at this level are starters for a decade or more, but never quite get over the hump.

[slag]

Who cares?

Fuck Aikman

[EagleFanInMD]

Is Matt Ryan, Russell Wilson, Joe Flacco Hall of Fame QB's?

[DEERSPINE GUY]

I THINK WE'LL KNOW MORE WHEN THEY HAVE A FULL CAREER.

I'D LIKE TO SEE 5 GET IN, HE'S AN EAGLE, BUT JUST DON'T THINK HE WILL. ALL THEM LOSSES IN NFC TITLE GAMES, WHEN BEING FAVORED WILL BE THE DIFFERENCE. THAT DAMN TAMPA BAY LOSE WILL HAUNT US AND HIM FOREVER.

HE COULD HAVE BEEN A HERO. LAST GAME AT THE VET. THIS CONVERSATION WOULDN'T BE TAKING PLACE.

BUT HEY SB CHAMPS NOW. NEVER TAKE THAT AWAY FROM US.....YEA US.

[art vandelay]

I think Wilson will get in. Probably wouldn't if he retired today, but with a few more seasons as his current self and/or another deep postseason run and he's in.