Lesean McCoy is wasted here

[nerd]

well actually, those sites are becoming more informed as more access to coaches film comes out.

[Drama Queen]

exactly.

[Drama Queen]

I understand what you want.

...but if the Eagles were to pull off the same deal that Cleveland received, they'd get a low end 1st rounder. I don't really think subtracting and taking a chance on a low 1st rounding would be an addition by subtraction for this team.

[CbEagle]

Guards are the easiest to replace, dump todd next year and draft a mid round or free agent and vey good oline in 14

[The Ref]

well actually, those sites are becoming more informed as more access to coaches film comes out.

coaches film has always been available to those who ask. I used to get VHS tapes in the late 90's. Not always the most current games, but within the same season.

[Melchior]

Yeah. I know. That's been talked about. By NFL coaches. Those kind of sites are laughingstocks. Even the best minds in the league, actually working for NFL teams, have zero idea what a player was asked to do on any play.

You can't grade a player when you have zero information about what his assigned task was on any play. Those sites are jokes. Arlington style.

So how do scouts evaluate college players when they may not know what they were asked to do?

[The Ref]

So how do scouts evaluate college players when they may not know what they were asked to do?

measurable's and interviewing their coaches. That's what scouts do. They don't just watch film, they have face time with people who know. That's what those sites don't do and that's why they're mostly just guessing.

[Melchior]

OK, so when Mathis blocks guys and opens up huge holes for Shady, he's actually fucking up the block? I'm confused here. What more do you need to know? He blocks the shit out of people and McCoy puts up 150+ yards every game.

Now if you want to take issue with them rating Jamaal Charles and Evan Mathis higher than Shady, then I agree.

[J_Cuz31]

and we trust your opinion because?

Hahaha, because, you know, "Superexpando."