McNabb one of the Top 32 Greatest QB's Ever

[Irish George]

sure!

Seriously ???

everybody knows that's why Warren Moon is on there. Frankly Im surprised they didn't go with Charlie Batch to even things out a little racially.

[Irish George]

I usually ignot that guy's posts

that was about as bad as it gets

[Irish George]

not having seen the list...

32 QBs is pretty selective. The NFL has been around for a long time. Any best-ever list will include guys I never watched. Guys from different eras like Sammy Baugh. But I think you could name 32 QBs better than McNabb. With the assumption that every QB in the HOF is better than McNabb, since McNabb won't get in, it's pretty easy to name 8 other QBs not yet in the HOF better than McNabb.

it is bogus if Baugh and Otto Graham are not on it.

[Irish George]

MOON???

Not every HoF QB is better than McNabb. I'd take McNabb over Namath, Blanda, Aikman (anyone could have won with those teams and likely put up equal numbers), and Moon off the top of my head. The one year he actually had a legit #1 receiver he went to a Super Bowl. Can't overstate how hard that is when you're 2nd and 3rd best receivers are Todd Pinkston and Freddie Mitchell.

you must never have seen Moon play. Just a ridiculous statement.

[ishimonster]

Russell Wilson

So is Russell Wilson, though. So there's that.

Also, according to the same guys, the player responsible for the Greatest Play of All-Time we're trying to trade for a 3rd round pick, so maybe Philly just loves discarding All-Time Greats.

Just beat Peyton Manning in the first round.

Edit: Oh and McNabb beat Warner.
...