Idk if Barkley is worth keeping over Sanchez

[Ellsworth]

But he sure as hell has better touch, accuracy, and feel for the game than Sanchez does.

Every DC in NFL knows Sanchez either can't or won't throw deep so can alter their plan accordingly. Barkley at least has the ability and balls/confidence to go over the top of a D and keep them honest.

[Prowler]

Some of Barkley's completions look like floaters to me

Up for grabs against starting DB's.

[BigSlizz]

This is the first time I've seen that ability as an Eagle. He looked like a super noodle arm in the past.

[Ellsworth]

No question. He's not perfect in any way. I'm just comparing him to Sanchez.

[Ellsworth]

I think that shoulder injury he suffered at end of his USC career had a long term effect on him. Perhaps he's finally closer to 100% and healed up.

Perhaps not. Ain't exactly going against the 91 Eagles D today.

But he's got intangibles that Sanchez doesn't have.

[E-money]

I'd rather see G. J. Kinne play QB than Sanchez.

This offense makes everybody look good... except for Mark Sanchez.

[Ground_Meat]

But he sure as hell has better touch, accuracy, and feel for the game than Sanchez does.

Every DC in NFL knows Sanchez either can't or won't throw deep so can alter their plan accordingly. Barkley at least has the ability and balls/confidence to go over the top of a D and keep them honest.

personally, i dont like either...sanchez is better. barkley did just have a very nice progression there on the dump-down to the RB...showed some great patience.

[Ellsworth]

Barkley went through 4-5 reads on that check down.

[Chupacabra]

This Bennett kid playing for Indy looks better than both of them.

[Drama Queen]

Barkley looked pretty good

But he sure as hell has better touch, accuracy, and feel for the game than Sanchez does.

Every DC in NFL knows Sanchez either can't or won't throw deep so can alter their plan accordingly. Barkley at least has the ability and balls/confidence to go over the top of a D and keep them honest.

and had a little more pop on the ball.

His ability to set his feet on that roll out strike to Matthews was excellent.

[nerd]

This Bennett kid playing for Indy looks better than both of them.

That Bennett kid looked like shit

[Pete]

So follow my logic here

That Bennett kid looked like shit

Barkley does well this preseason (or just better than horrid), the Eagles finally trade him to Indy...

compensation is: Bryan Bennett, who played for Chip at Oregon.

[Melchior]

Barkley does well this preseason (or just better than horrid), the Eagles finally trade him to Indy...

compensation is: Bryan Bennett, who played for Chip at Oregon.

I doubt it happens this season, but if Barkley continues to play like that in PS, he'll probably be the #2 next year and Chip will likely draft another QB to sit in the 3rd spot and develop.

I really liked what I saw from Barkley. His arm looks a lot better, especially on downfield throws. His shorter stuff had some zip and even though his deep balls arc/float a bit, he seemed to compensate with anticipation and good ball placement.

The deflection/pick was ultimately on him, but that was just a good play by the defense.

Jordan Matthews looks like a fucking monster and would've went off if Sanchez wasn't throwing every ball 5 feet over the head of his receivers.